Chris Franzek: Today, we’re here with Brendan Smith and West Chapman from Stout’s Portfolio Valuation and Fund Advisory businesses to talk about private credit, which is a topic that’s been in the news of late. West, as a former institutional investor in private funds, how would you rate the overall health of the private credit fund market?
West Chapman: Based on data from PitchBook, fundraising in the private credit space has remained healthy between 2020 and 2025. Concurrently, capital flows into private credit funds from the recently tapped retail market have been growing. Earlier this year, as AI took center stage, questions arose about how companies’ business models would be impacted by AI and, as a result, how AI would impact the valuations of the securities in those companies’ capital structures. We all had a front-row seat as transactions were canceled, secondary transactions and tender offers hit the market, and news of redemptions and redemption suspensions hit the press.
Chris Franzek: It has been an event-filled few months in private credit. Brendan, it seems that the phrase “private credit valuation” has been in the press more in the past six months than in the past 20 years combined. If the media coverage wasn’t enough, at the end of September, the SEC issued a Statement highlighting valuation, reporting and audit requirements specific to the world of private credit. Are we in the midst of a private credit valuation crisis?
Brendan Smith: Perhaps “crisis” is a strong word. As West noted, fundraising is still healthy in the institutional market, and new retail products continue to hit the market. There are a lot of questions about valuations even though most private credit funds retain one or more independent valuation firms, like Stout, to provide an independent view on the valuations of their assets on a periodic basis. That being said, the fact that the SEC took the opportunity to issue a statement reminding participants in the private credit ecosystem of their valuation, reporting, and audit responsibilities demonstrates that the SEC is focused on the quality.
West Chapman: Brendan, with my former Chief Risk Officer and Institutional Investor hat on, it always bothered me when I’d see the same asset marked differently by two or more funds in which my firm was invested. With increasing price transparency in the market, it seems that we’re seeing that happen more, and I expect that very transparency played a part in the SEC’s reasoning to issue its latest Statement. Is that normal?
Brendan Smith: Private markets are opaque, and historically, only some institutional investors had the resources or took the time to notice varying marks on the same asset as you, and/or the SEC, did. With data and technology becoming increasingly capable, it has become increasingly easy to see discrepancies in asset valuations disclosed in a variety of public filings, and some of the differences are large. Today, there may still be reasons for managers’ valuations to differ (like lender information asymmetry), but increasing transparency is providing objective insights into “market participant” assumptions/views that are required under the fair value accounting rules and that the SEC specifically called out in their September Statement.
Chris Franzek: Brendan, while the accounting rules require consideration of market participant views and there are increasing reference points around that, what about the rest of the valuation process? If we focus on private credit, how different are market data sources, data from portfolio companies, and/or valuation models across investors and valuation firms?
Brendan Smith: For performing loans, the processes and inputs are very similar across general partners (GPs), independent valuation providers, and auditors. Reporting packages from portfolio companies and investors may vary somewhat from company to company, but generally they contain similar disclosures around performance: financial statements, board decks, and compliance certificates. Documents and data from portfolio companies are used by GPs and third parties to the valuation process to inform their judgment about portfolio company performance. Portfolio company performance is combined with market data to populate valuation models. Accounting Standards Codification 820 instructs us that we should be considering a market participant view (as the buyer at the valuation date) when formulating valuation assumptions and inputs. The SEC reminds us of the requirement to consider the market participant view of portfolio company performance and current market conditions.
Chris Franzek: What about pricing from the secondary market or publicly available valuations for the same assets? Are those data sources regularly considered?
Brendan Smith: Secondary market data should be considered when available. One of the challenges with secondary market data is that most transactions involve portfolios of assets, so it can be hard to identify the price of an individual asset within the portfolio. Publicly available marks are not always available for the same assets, and when they are, they are often subject to a lag due to public filing deadlines.
That said, while there’s a lag, you could use hindsight to compare how one’s view of an asset compares to other holders of the same asset in prior periods and use that as a benchmark. This might not necessarily change a view on valuation, but it’s helpful context for boards and other constituents when evaluating the reasonableness of the valuation process. Third-party valuation agents and auditors should be doing the same thing during their valuation processes and discussing any meaningful differences with clients before finalizing their work, as we do at Stout.
West Chapman: Brendan, you didn’t include data from rating agencies as an input to the valuation process. Why?
Brendan Smith: There are some managers that retain a rating agency to provide some level of credit assessment on individual loans, but GPs that use rating agencies are in the minority. Generally, the most common practice in the industry for assessing credit and changes in credit worthiness is to make a subjective assessment based on a relatively small number of financial ratios. The process is generally the same for independent valuation firms and auditors.
However, at Stout, we’ve built a credit assessment model that includes public and private information to give us a consistent and objective assessment of credit since the inception of the loan as well as period over period. We find this process to be more transparent as well as GP- and auditor-friendly, and it can be consistently applied period to period.
Chris Franzek: Brendan, from the process that you’ve described, it sounds like there’s a lot of coordination between various parties, lots of data/documents moving around, and a growing number of market inputs to coordinate. How long does this process take, and what tools are typically employed?
Brendan Smith: Within GPs, the timing of the valuation process varies and is dependent on the size of the loan portfolio as well as the GP’s internal valuation process. Excel is still the predominant tool for valuations by GPs, third-party valuation firms, and auditors. While flexible, it leaves room for inconsistencies across investments/teams, errors, time to update, and challenges performing portfolio sensitivities.
Some funds have started leveraging external tools to help their internal valuation process. Some tools are better than others, and some integrate with other tools better than others but result in a patchwork process that lacks end-to-end integration, especially when it comes to working with third parties.
West Chapman: To continue Brendan’s thought, we’ve actually seen the patchwork methodology across all asset classes. GPs have built processes that “work” but often have one or more components that limit scalability, transparency, and/or integration from end to end. That’s why Stout built Drivr! Our goal was to start with gathering data at the portfolio company and to integrate the steps through portfolio monitoring and analytics, the valuation process, and reporting — whether internal or external — while maximizing efficiency and transparency.
Brendan Smith: Whether a GP has six or 600 investments, Drivr provides GPs with a secure, integrated, scalable, and transparent environment through which to monitor and value their investments, including complete integration with Stout’s independent valuation team (and, if desired, their auditors). It’s really a first in the industry and can take a two-to-three-week valuation process and compress it into days while providing full transparency.
Chris Franzek: What about AI? I can do some pretty good analytics just by using Claude or Harvey. A few months ago, I was reading about “SaaS-ageddon.” Isn’t this exactly the wrong time to adopt a software-as-a-service (SaaS) solution for one’s valuation needs?
West Chapman: Some SaaS business models will be tested by AI. You can do a lot these days with Claude to support periodic valuation processes. However, Stout’s Drivr brings the analytics that AI promises without hallucinations and couples those analytics with institutional security and support and integrated databases enabling more complex analytics.
Drivr provides a new level of transparency to the valuation process, and it is coupled with Stout’s best-in-class professionals as technical valuation business partners to deliver independent valuation opinions, answer technical valuation questions, or provide market insights. Those are capabilities that fintech solutions lack.
Brendan Smith: I’ll add that it’s quite common for our portfolio valuation clients to reach out with questions outside of the cadence of their regular valuation processes. It may be a question related to their valuation policy or a technical question related to the valuation implications of a deal structure that they’re negotiating. Ad hoc discussions are an important part of our client relationships, and we’re making that part of Drivr as well.
Chris Franzek: Not all GPs have the same needs. How does Drivr meet the needs of such a diverse group of managers?
West Chapman: Drivr has been designed to be configurable. More time has been invested designing each functionality such that there is more than one way to perform a given task. Configurability is short of fully custom, but we have found that configurability can bring 90% of the custom benefits without the development time or cost.
Also, Drivr has been configured such that a client can use Drivr as a SaaS product or as part of a more traditional professional services engagement where Stout is providing assurance on a client’s valuations or providing a range of values on a client’s investments.
If a SaaS client has a particular investment for which an independent valuation is needed on a given date, Drivr streamlines that process as the data and investment terms are already in Stout’s workflow, ready for Stout’s valuation team to engage and deliver an opinion.
The other way that Drivr helps clients is that we meet our clients at their data and their data collection process. In other words, if a GP needs help establishing workflows to collect data from portfolio companies, Drivr can collect any data/KPI with any frequency: daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. If a client has an existing process and the GP can give us structured data directly, we can consume data from a data tape (.xls or .csv file), an application programming interface (API), or an intermediary like Snowflake or Databricks. Lastly, if a GP needs help extracting data from portfolio company documents, we can provide a managed service to ensure timely and accurate data extraction for the client.
Chris Franzek: What about switching costs? How easy is it for a GP to change valuation providers and/or to incorporate a new technology into their process?
Brendan Smith: The short answer is that it depends. We find that we can seamlessly onboard a new client that has been using another valuation firm regardless of whether the client wants to move the whole portfolio at once or over a few quarters. Stout’s process fits into any GP’s valuation process. Leveraging Drivr, we can quickly and easily upload the history of each investment and the terms of each investment such that onboarding and/or switching costs are minimized. Whether leveraging a client’s use of Snowflake to ingest data directly or using Drivr’s AI to extract data from prior valuation reports, it’s never been easier to change technology platforms or valuation providers.
Chris Franzek: West and Brendan, are there any final thoughts you’d like to bring up?
West Chapman: Investors and regulators look for consistency and objectivity. Data and technology are rapidly evolving such that efficiency, transparency, consistency, and objectivity are intersecting for the first time. GPs don’t have to sacrifice one to get the others. Drivr delivers all of the above while reducing fund expenses and shortening reporting cycles.
Brendan Smith: Process improvements that were only possible in one’s imagination a few years ago have become both technologically feasible and doable in a cost-and time-effective manner. With Drivr, GPs no longer need to piece together multiple technologies and service providers to monitor and value their portfolios and scale their operations, promising to improve the consistency, objectivity, efficiency, and transparency of the overall valuation process, which we believe gets to the heart of the SEC’s valuation and reporting concerns.
Explore Drivr now.