Megan Lisa Jones co-authored this piece. Megan is a tax partner at Holland & Knight and a member of its global wealth and family office practice group.

Corporate capital structures for decades have centered on debt and equity, but artificial intelligence and token-based business models are beginning to complicate that framework.

Technology companies can now combine stock with tokens, token warrants, digital incentives, access rights, and governance mechanisms. Meanwhile, AI businesses are developing new ways to monetize a variety of services.

The result is a structure in which economic value may no longer reside entirely in corporate equity, and where tax treatment can be far less settled than for traditional stock and debt.

A token doesn’t necessarily represent ownership in a legal entity. Its value may instead depend on network growth, utility, scarcity, trading demand, or contractual rights. When companies have both shareholders and token holders, management must understand how those rights interact and where the economic value of the enterprise resides.

AI may make these structures more relevant. An AI platform can monetize models, computing capacity, proprietary data, inference services, or autonomous-agent services while using tokens to reward third parties that provide specialized models.

This can create strategic flexibility, but it also raises fundamental questions: What does the token represent, how does it affect equity value, and who captures the upside as the ecosystem grows?

Token-based economics can be consequential in mergers and acquisitions. Buyers must determine what happens to tokens issued to founders, employees, or customers, for example.

Tax adds another layer: A transaction may not receive the same favorable treatment when tokens or other digital rights are involved rather than just stock. These issues should be addressed during transaction structuring, not after closing.

Unsettled Tax Treatment

Whatever the business rationale for a token, its tax treatment will drive structuring decisions. The starting point is that the IRS treats digital assets as property rather than currency.

Under Notice 2014-21, general rules for property transactions apply. A sale or exchange of a token generally produces gain or loss. Receiving tokens as compensation, as payment for goods or services, or through activities such as staking or an airdrop can result in ordinary income measured by the value of the tokens once the recipient has dominion and control over them.

The guidance tells us how a holder is taxed when it receives or disposes of a digital asset. It doesn’t tell us what a particular token is. It might be treated as stock, debt, a partnership interest, an option or forward contract, or simply property, and there is no comprehensive authority on how to make that call.

Nor does securities law answer the question. A token that is a security under the Howey test isn’t necessarily stock or debt for tax purposes.

Can a token be equity? Possibly. For tax purposes, equity generally means stock in a corporation or an interest in a partnership. A token that gives its holder a true ownership interest in the issuer, such as rights to distributions, liquidation proceeds, and a vote, may be treated that way. Many tokens don’t. They provide access to a network or a say in a protocol, and the issuer may be a foundation, a non-US entity, or no entity at all. Far from clear is whether those tokens represent equity in anything.

Can a token be debt? Again, possibly, but the answer will turn on the terms. Courts have long distinguished debt from equity by looking at factors such as an unconditional obligation to pay a fixed sum on a fixed date, a stated rate of interest, the holder’s right to enforce payment, subordination to other creditors, and whether the holder participates in management.

Most tokens have few of these features. Some do, such as a token redeemable for a fixed amount and, if a token is debt, the original issue discount and interest deduction rules apply. Token warrants, convertible features, and arrangements in which tokens are promised now and delivered later complicate the analysis.

The distinction matters because the tax consequences aren’t the same. A corporation generally doesn’t recognize gain when it issues its own stock, but there is no comparable rule for tokens. An issuer that sells tokens must consider whether it has taxable income at the time of sale or whether recognition can be deferred until it performs.

Tokens issued to employees and service providers raise questions of timing, valuation, and withholding, including whether a Section 83(b) election is available.

In an acquisition, tokens delivered to selling holders are unlikely to count as stock of the acquirer, which can affect whether the transaction qualifies for tax-deferred treatment. And benefits that depend on stock status, such as qualified small business stock treatment, won’t extend to a token.

The law in this area hasn’t caught up with the technology. There’s no comprehensive statute, regulation, or ruling addressing whether a token is debt or equity, and existing guidance deals only with specific fact patterns, such as hard forks, airdrops, and staking, rather than the questions on which capital structure decisions depend.

Companies should expect to take positions without clear authority, document the basis for them, and revisit them as guidance develops. Just as important, tax advisers should be involved when the token is designed, not after it has been issued.

Questions to Ask

For management teams and boards considering a token-based model, the most important question may be the simplest: What business problem is the token solving?

From there, companies should understand the economic rights being created, how those rights interact with existing shareholders, how tokens will be valued and accounted for, what happens during a financing or acquisition, and what tax and regulatory consequences may arise.

The opportunity is real. AI and digital assets may allow companies to create forms of ownership, participation, and economic incentive that were difficult to implement through traditional capital structures alone.

But greater flexibility comes with greater complexity. For founders, CFOs, investors, and boards, the challenge will be to understand not merely whether a token can be issued, but where the underlying economic value resides and how that value should be governed, valued, taxed, and ultimately transferred.

This content was originally published in Bloomberg Tax.