Court Case Commentaries and Reviews Expert Analyses for Informed Decision Making

Subscribe to Case Alerts

Court Case Commentaries and Reviews Expert Analyses for Informed Decision Making

Subscribe to Case Alerts

Stout regularly researches significant trust & estate tax and valuation-related cases and provides expert analyses. We examine the background behind a case as well as the court’s proceedings leading up to a decision.

Our professionals regularly work on high-stakes cases in federal and state jurisdictions and have been retained by top U.S. law firms and attorneys, with more than 1,600 expert appearances collectively across 47 states. Additionally, we work directly with government agencies, including the Department of Justice, the Department of Labor, the Internal Revenue Service, and the Securities and Exchange Commission, to resolve our clients' issues. We utilize our extensive experience both inside and outside of the courtroom to analyze recent cases so others can make informed decisions.

Trust & Estate — Tax Court Cases

Hollywood Star

Michael Jackson’s Estate Moonwalks Past the IRS in Tax Court Battle

The opinion on the King of Pop’s assets may serve as a helpful guide for experts involved in the valuation of the right of publicity and copyrights.

Photo of court room

Tax Court Ruling Highlights Importance of Formula Clauses

The Tax Court’s decision reflected that the intent of donors is only as strong as the precise language in the formula clause.

Photo of gavel

IRS’ Game Theory Argument Gets Torpedoed by Expert’s Hot Tubbing

The decision in the case will likely be highly discussed for many years to come.

Photo of gold justice statue

In Grieve Case, Tax Court Reaffirms Fair Market Value Standard

Stout’s appraisal of the taxpayer’s LLCs reiterated the accepted approaches to valuing minority interests in privately held investment entities.

Photo of person at desk and charts

Estate of Aaron U. Jones v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Tax Court finds Income Approach is more appropriate than others in valuation of minority interests of two companies.

Valuation Disputes — Court Cases

Phtoto of computer store

Delaware Court Decides AT&T Breached Fiduciary Duty of Loyalty to Minority Partners in Freeze-Out Transaction

Case Review: In re Cellular Telephone Partnership Appraisal Coordinated C.A. No. 6885-VCL

Photo of buildings

Delaware Chancery Court Again Embraces the Adjusted Deal Price Methodology

But while the starting deal price is clear in HFF, more nuance is required to determine the adjustments.

Photo of theatre

A Familiar Plot With Several Twists in Regal-Cineworld Case

Delaware Chancery Court’s fair value determination is slightly above the deal price in a merger between these two national movie theater chains.

Photo of industrial site

In Final Hartman Ruling, Words Literally Matter

In this shareholder dispute, plain meaning of the words on the page ruled the day in Indiana Supreme Court.

business team

Delaware Chancery Court Sides With Petitioner’s Expert in Appraisal Proceeding

Lacking market-based evidence of fair value, the court relied on traditional valuation methodologies in its decision.

Photo of rental properties

Delaware Chancery Court Finds Fair Price Was Paid in UIP Stock Sale

Applying the entire fairness standard, the court ruled the defendants met their burden.

Photo of minerals

In Re: Appraisal of Stillwater Mining Company – Delaware Court Opts for Deal Price – Again

The court found that while the sale process was not perfect, the facts of this case, when viewed as a whole, compared favorably with the facts in other recent Court of Chancery cases.

Photo of pipeline

In Re: Appraisal of Columbia Pipeline Group, Inc. – Delaware Court Opts for Deal Price

The Delaware Court of Chancery opined against the petitioners' proposed valuation.

Photo of grocery store

In Re: Appraisal of Jarden Corporation – Market Price and DCF Analysis

The Delaware Chancery Court relied on the unaffected market price and performed an independent DCF analysis to corroborate the most persuasive market evidence.

Computer graph

Fair Value Methods of the Delaware Chancery Court: Deal Price Less Synergies

We discuss the valuation of synergies and present a framework for allocating value between buyer and target in an M&A transaction.

Image of headphones

Delaware Supreme Court Reverses Aruba Decision

In ruling, the court uses deal price less synergies in deriving the fair value of Aruba Networks, Inc.

Photo of warehouse

Kress v. U.S. Offers Important Guidance for Appraisers

The gift tax matter covered the Guideline Public Company Method, S corps versus C corps, discounts for lack of marketability, transfer restrictions, and more.

Image of graph

Long-Term Growth Rate Trends in Delaware Chancery Decisions

Recent decisions illuminate the Delaware Court of Chancery’s perspective on long-term growth rates in discounted cash flow analyses.

Photo of stethoscope

Domain v. Shah Highlights Several Key Valuation Considerations

The Delaware Chancery Court ruled that Shah be awarded fair value of his LLC member interest rather than the book value of his capital account.

Photo of computer

Merger Price Carries the Weight in Delaware Chancery’s Solera Decision

The Delaware Court of Chancery’s ruling was consistent with previous appraisal cases and found that representative DCF models were not credible.

Photo of kitchen

In Norcraft, the Delaware Court Offers Further Valuation Guidance

The opinion in Blueblade v. Norcraft marks another instance in which the Delaware Chancery Court exclusively relied on DCF analysis in determining fair value.

Computer screen

Delaware Chancery Court Decision in Appraisal of AOL Inc.

Stout's expert analysis of factors used in the Delaware Chancery Court ruling in In re Appraisal of AOL Inc. to determine the fair value of the Verizon transaction.